Coinbase Cites Binance Case for Interlocutory Appeal in SEC lawsuit
In the latest development, crypto exchange Coinbase has submitted a notice requesting an interlocutory appeal while citing Judge Jackson’s decision in the Binance BNB case. Last week, Judge Jackson said that Binance’s BNB token sale in the secondary markets doesn’t qualify as securities. As a result, Coinbase has questioned how two different judges can treat two exchanges differently over regulatory rules.
Coinbase CLO Raises Question on District Court Judgments
Coinbase Chief Legal Officer Paul Grewal highlighted a significant discrepancy in the judicial treatment of crypto transactions in the United States. Grewal said that two learned district courts analyzing “economically identical transactions” of the two biggest US exchanges have 180-degree diametrically opposite conclusions on whether the transactions qualify as securities transactions.
He also slammed the SEC’s litigation-focused approach toward crypto regulations adding that there are inconsistent rules for market participants across different jurisdictions. “The result of the SEC’s litigation-focused approach to crypto regulation is that market participants now face different rules, not only in different courts in this District but in different federal courts around the country,” noted Grewal.
While emphasizing the uniformity in the legal standards, Grewal stated that Liability shouldn’t depend on the court suing the exchange or the judge being assigned the case.
Liability shouldn’t depending on what what court you get sued in or what judge is assigned to your case. Earlier today we filed a notice in our enforcement case against @SECGov about Judge Jackson’s decision in the case against Binance. This decision squarely rejected the SEC’s… pic.twitter.com/j41nsvVzDq
— paulgrewal.eth (@iampaulgrewal) July 1, 2024
Also Read: Coinbase Initiates Lawsuit Against SEC, FDIC Over Debanking Crypto Entities
Some Background to the Notice
Earlier this year in April 2024, Coinbase requested Judge Failla to pause the legal proceedings in the SEC lawsuit. The exchange demanded an interlocutory appeal citing “substantial grounds for differences of opinion” on whether the Howey Test shall be applicable to crypto transactions taking place in the secondary market.
Back then, Coinbase cited Judge Torres’s opinion in the Ripple vs. SEC lawsuit that XRP, when traded in the secondary market does not satisfy the Howey Test. Coinbase said that such dueling opinions coming from different district judges make it difficult to know what the actual law is.
In responding to Coinbase’s request, the U.S. Securities and Exchange Commission said that “no court has followed Ripple” while applying the Howey Test to the secondary market sales.
AlsoRead: ConsenSys Responds to SEC Lawsuit Over Metamask
The post Coinbase Cites Binance Case for Interlocutory Appeal in SEC lawsuit appeared first on CoinGape.
